AI: First Slowly, Then Suddenly
The image that comes to mind is the way the ocean assaults a seawall. It does not do so in one dramatic crushing blow. It does so gradually. Repeated waves remove the sand and soil supporting the wall, while saltwater, turbulence, and storm weakens the structure until it collapses.
Hold that vision in your head as you read the description of the way AI crept into this particular workforce, the way it took out not only the author’s job at an education tech startup in Silicon Valley but twenty percent of her coworkers in How AI Replaced Me. The technology, she said, moved through the workforce like a new religion. “In the tech industry, it’s not good enough to just use AI. You have to believe in it, too.”
She was surprised to have been laid off since her job as Customer Success Manager had almost exclusively involved human interactions. Keep that in your mind as you consider the way AI moved slowly, then suddenly, beyond the world of programming, planning, data, and spreadsheets into the one of human dynamics and relationships.
Most disheartening was her description of the underlying dehumanizing process. First slowly: run documents through Claude; use it to generate decks; here’s an app to monitor your work; input your daily business.Then suddenly: here’s the door, have a nice day
One might reasonably conclude these days that each and every position currently conducted through a computer interface is vulnerable such that no human is safe from the superior processing power enabled within that digital universe.
To paraphrase, as applied to even the tech industry itself, first they came for the programmers and I did not speak out, then they came for the customer reps and I did not speak out, and then they came for me – and then there was no one to speak for me.
While the author seems to regard unionization as one answer, what comes to mind is an image of that workplace represented by the seawall and then of AI by the relentless ocean. Or, in a quote by local Boulder personality Len Barron as he addressed a World Affairs Conference a few decades ago, “In a perfectly efficient society, man is redundant.”
Please note the following RSVP Policy for Member Monday: RSVP sign-up opens up at 11:00am on Fridays via the City Club weekly Newsletter. Seats are first-come, first-served: the first 14 secure a spot at the table, the last 3 on the couch. Cancellations must be made 24 hours in advance or the standard Social Lunch rate applies.